Monday, December 17, 2007

New Album Releases

This includes Pink Floyd's box set which has seen surprisingly negative criticism

Scale:
A- to A+: Universally Acclaimed

B- to B+: Overall positive reviews

C- to C+: Mixed reviews

D- to D+: Overall negative reveiws

F- to F+: Horrible




1. Saves the Day-Under the Boards
Average Critic Score: C+
Average Fan Score: B

Scores:
All Music Guide: B
The Onion: C
Spin: D+
Alternative Press: B
Boston Globe: D+


2. Wu-Tang Clan-8 Diagrams
Average Critic Score: B
Average Fan Score: A

Scores:
All Music Guide: A-
Rolling Stone: B
Pitchfork: A-
PopMatters: A-
The Onion: B-


3. Bow Wow & Omarion-Face Off
Average Critic Score: B-
Average Fan Score: B

Scores:
All Music Guide: C+
Rolling Stone: C+
Billboard: B
Blender: C+
Entertainment Weekly: A-


4. Scarface-M.A.D.E.
Average Critic Score: B+
Average Fan Score: C-

Scores:
All Music Guide: B
Rolling Stone: C+
Entertainment Weekly: B+
The New York Times: A-
RapReviews.Com: A-


5. Dr. Dog-We All Belong
Average Critic Score: B
Average Fan Score: A

Scores:
All Music Guide: A
Rolling Stone: B
Pitchfork: C
PopMatters: C
The Onion: B+


6. Beanie Sigel-The Solution
Average Critic Score: B
Average Fan Score: B+

Scores:
Rolling Stone: C+
Pitchfork: B-
Billboard: A-
Blender: C+
The New York Times: A-


7. Pink Floyd-Oh By the Way
Average Critic Score: C+
Average Fan Score: B+

Scores:
All Music Guide: A-
Billboard: A-
Pitchfork: D+
Amazon.com: C
Uncut: C+

No comments: